In order for a logical syllogism to be valid, all premises must be true, and the conclusion must be forced by the premises. With that in mind, and knowing that many KJV (TR) Only advocates will howl at the idea that something they take on faith is evaluated on the basis of logic, I offer this:
1. The Bible promises that God will preserve his Word
2. The only possible definition of preserve is "perfection"
3. The only text that is "perfect" is the KJV (TR).
The first premise is entirely true. God did promise to preserve his Word.
The second premise is an interpretation of Scripture, that can be debated, as all interpretations must be, it is not correct by the standards of Church history to say that it MUST be the only interpretation.
The conclusion can no longer be valid, since the 2nd premise is untrue, but even if it was, the conclusion is not a result of the first two premises. There is nothing different about the KJV (TR) from any other text or translation that sets it apart as "perfect". Advocates of that position will claim otherwise, will make their chosen favorite the standard by which all others are judged, but they cannot escape the clear facts of history, and must in the end retreat into saying that their position MUST be taken by faith (with all the dire consequences of apostasy heaped upon those who disagree).
There is a lot of confusion, name calling, tangents that have nothing to do with the main issue, and outright lies being spread about this issue within the Church. It is enough to make the head of an ordinary lay person spin, and not a few pastors as well. But, in the end, everything comes back to premise #2 and the desperate attempt to prove that the KJV (or TR) satisfies that standard.
The sad thing is, none of this is necessary, we have an amazingly, providentially, preserved Word of God, living and active, powerful and mighty, available to us in English in an array of sound and beneficial choices. Not only that, but this entire discussion relegates God's work through his Word among the other peoples of the world to sideshow, when in reality God's work among the English speaking peoples, and the Western cultures is but one part of his amazing work all over the world. Everyday the percentage of Christians reading the Bible in English shrinks because the number of Christians reading it in other languages is growing by leaps and bounds!
Randy,
ReplyDeleteYou missed it. You are not stating the position correctly.
Ok, so which part of not correct? I am simply repeating what I've read/heard from various advocates of these two similar positions (I know that there are some differences between the two, but they have much in common). Feel free to offer a differently worded premise or conclusion.
ReplyDelete