The Franklin Christian Ministerium released its warning against the Torah Clubs and the First Fruits of Zion on February 16th, of 2023, along with a detailed listing of primary source quotations illustrating our concerns {Now updated to include further damning quotations from the Malchut 2022 Conference: The Unorthodox Beliefs of the First Fruits of Zion. If you're read the previous version, it will be worth you time to see the new quotes too}. We shared this information with every church in the county and with our own congregations and networks. I have had many conversations, as have other pastors, with fellow men and women serving in pastoral leadership about this topic, both before the ministerium's statement and after.
Some may be wondering what the response has been, officially or otherwise, from either the First Fruits of Zion organization, the local Torah Clubs leaders, or any individuals that are/were participating in this.
1. There has been no response from the First Fruits of Zion organization.
We do not know whether they are aware of our objections to their false teaching or not, but given that this organization's leadership believes that it is ordained by God to overturn the global Church (seriously, they believe their effort will bring about the End Times, no less), it would not be unusual for those with such lofty self conceptions to take attempts at correction from the established (traditional, apostolic, biblical) Church as a sign that they're on the right path.
2. There has been no response, directly to the ministerium, from the leadership of the local Torah Clubs.
We have not seen any effort to correct, supposedly, false impressions or conclusions (hard to do that when we shared twenty pages of direct quotes as evidence) about this movement or its theology addressed to either the ministerium as a whole, or individual pastoral leaders. Having been called out publicly by an ecumenical representation of the Church for rejecting historic and apostolic orthodoxy, no direct response has been forthcoming.
It has been noted that local Torah Club leaders have shared on social media that they are being "persecuted" by a few local church pastors, and claims have been made of support by many church leaders in this, although none to my knowledge have publicly defended this theology, but none of these online conversations have been directed at us. Along those lines, there have been various things shared via social media equating the local Torah Club leaders with Martin Luther {ironic given the antipathy of the FFOZ toward the Protestant Reformation: Rethinking the Five Solae, a book they have published claiming that the roots of Protestant theology are the cause of antisemitism}, and presumably the Franklin Ministerium with the Catholic authorities that opposed him. As a Baptist minister, I find it odd that an organization that condemns Sola Scriptura, would have local leaders quoting Martin Luther's famous, "Unless I am convinced by the testimony of the Scriptures or by clear reason (for I do not trust either in the pope or in the councils alone, since it is well known that they have often erred and contradicted themselves), I am bound by the Scriptures I have quoted, and my conscience is captive to the Word of God."
3. When it comes to individual Torah Club participants, we have reason to hope.
Thankfully, I have not had anyone in my congregation fall prey to this movement, some of my fellow servants of Christ have not been so fortunate. While the local leadership remains, as far as we can tell, defiant of orthodoxy, Church history, and local pastors' pleadings, we have seen some of those participating take a step away from the organization after hearing of our objections. I can only share anecdotal observations, but those have typically followed the pattern of someone with an already existing relationship being key. This is not a surprise, for all the bluster of punditry and online arguments that take place today, few people actually change their minds on important topics due to them. What does affect people, as it always has, is relationships. So pray for the Christians in our community that have relationships with Torah Club participants, may they act with wisdom and compassion when attempting to help those who have wandered from the Gospel.
4. How should we then pray for those influenced by the Torah Clubs?
We need your prayers. As a local Christian community we always need the support of prayer, this is no exception. Pray that those who have strayed from orthodoxy, {as most were previously deeply committed Christian believers, that's who FFOZ purposefully targets} will see the light of Truth and be given the grace of God to return to their first belief. Pray that pride and stubbornness would be vanquished, that previous fellowship with a local church will prove the stronger. And yes, pray for the local leaders of the Torah Clubs, as I have, should they return to orthodoxy from this error it would have a profound affect upon so many others.
Thank you for supporting your local church pastor, we need it and appreciate it more than our words of gratitude can convey.
