Contrary to what you may have heard, prayer in schools (or anywhere else) has never been illegal. How could it be? Prayer is a conversation between yourself and God, one that nobody else is privy to, nor able to control. In addition to the continued availability of private prayer, prayer that is student initiated and student led (See You At the Pole for example) has always been, and will remain perfectly legal. {No, having a student lead a prayer over the loudspeaker while students are required to be quiet and listen is not the same thing}
I'm not talking about corporate worship, when the people of God are gathered together and one person leads either a pre-written or spontaneous prayer, as that individual (pastor or otherwise) is acting as a spokesperson for us and focusing our group prayer in one direction; we are praying
with him/her, they're not praying on our behalf; that's an important distinction. With that caveat in place, it is absolutely clear in Scripture that because of the nature of the New Covenant, with Jesus serving as our mediator, that we can approach God
directly in prayer. We have direct access to the Father.
Ephesians 3:12 New International Version
In him and through faith in him we may approach God with freedom and confidence.
Hebrews 4:16 New International Version
Let us then approach God’s throne of grace with confidence, so that we may receive mercy and find grace to help us in our time of need.
Romans 8:14-15 New International Version
For those who are led by the Spirit of God are the children of God. 15 The Spirit you received does not make you slaves, so that you live in fear again; rather, the Spirit you received brought about your adoption to sonship. And by him we cry, “Abba, Father.”
3. Rote, compelled, and thus insincere prayer (like worship) is not only not honoring to God, it actually offends and angers God.
What would mandated/compulsory prayer in public schools actually be? Would it be sincere acts of worship? How could it be for the millions of school children (and teachers) told to pray to a God in whom they do not believe, or told to pray in a way contrary to the dictates of their conscience? How could these prayers possibly be genuine and from the heart? What they would actually be is a repeated affront to God, as if God is compelled to bless our nation because we've required everyone to pray, as if God is beholden to us, and not the other way around. God will not be manipulated, and God will not be mocked.
Jeremiah 7:9-11 New International Version
“‘Will you steal and murder, commit adultery and perjury, burn incense to Baal and follow other gods you have not known, 10 and then come and stand before me in this house, which bears my Name, and say, “We are safe”—safe to do all these detestable things? 11 Has this house, which bears my Name, become a den of robbers to you? But I have been watching! declares the Lord.
Hosea 6:6 New International Version
For I desire mercy, not sacrifice, and acknowledgment of God rather than burnt offerings.
Isaiah 1:11-15 New International Version
“The multitude of your sacrifices—
what are they to me?” says the Lord.
“I have more than enough of burnt offerings,
of rams and the fat of fattened animals;
I have no pleasure
in the blood of bulls and lambs and goats.
12 When you come to appear before me,
who has asked this of you,
this trampling of my courts?
13 Stop bringing meaningless offerings!
Your incense is detestable to me.
New Moons, Sabbaths and convocations—
I cannot bear your worthless assemblies.
14 Your New Moon feasts and your appointed festivals
I hate with all my being.
They have become a burden to me;
I am weary of bearing them.
15 When you spread out your hands in prayer,
I hide my eyes from you;
even when you offer many prayers,
I am not listening.
Your hands are full of blood!
4. Requiring non-Christians to pray a Christian prayer hurts evangelism.
How does evangelism work? What are the most effective methods for sharing the Good News that Jesus Christ has died for our sins and been raised from the dead for our justification? An important question, and one studied and debated by those engaging in missions and evangelism both here in America and throughout the world. The answer to that question is never: force people to read the Bible, pray, and attend church. Why not? Because it doesn't work. Only God can make a planted seed grow, only the Holy Spirit can soften the hard heart of human rebellion. The only thing that compulsory participation, in a religion that you don't believe in, consistently causes in those it is forced upon, is resentment and anger. State mandated 'Christian' prayer demonstrates to Muslims, Hindus, or Atheists that we do not respect them as Americans, let alone as human beings, how exactly are we creating an opportunity for them to hear the Gospel?
5. A one-size-fits all prayer to God(s) that tries to please everybody, is the most likely outcome.
The last thing I want is a politician or a government employee writing the prayers that our children are required to listen to, and/or recite. A prayer not directed at God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit is not a Christian prayer. What kind of prayer would we be talking about? It would have to be one mandated/written by the Federal government at the Department of Education, and thus one designed to please Christians, Muslims, Jews, Hindus, Buddhists, Mormons, Agnostics, Atheists, and thus equally offensive to all and pleasing to nobody. I absolutely believe in intra-faith prayer, Protestants, Catholics, and Orthodox Christians can and should pray together. I absolutely do NOT believe in inter-faith prayer, for how can we pray together when we don't agree upon who we're praying to?
6. Focus on prayer in schools is thinking like an American 1st, a Christian 2nd.
This may be hard for some to accept, but as a Christian my citizenship is in Heaven. That I am an American, while being an honor and a blessing for which I give thanks and a responsibility that carries with it civic duties that I take very seriously, is still in the end, only incidental compared to knowing that my soul has been redeemed by the Blood of the Lamb. As such, I must always consider what is right in God's eyes, what is beneficial to the Church and its mission to share the Gospel, before considering what I think is right for America. Often the two are compatible, but there is a divergence more often than many of us are willing to admit. For example: It may benefit (at least in the short-term) America to 'win' at the expense of another nation economically or militarily, but those who live in that land are human beings just like me, created in the image of God, and thus either fellow followers of Jesus Christ, or those in need of the Gospel. Either way, as a Christian I look at the world, and my nation's place within it, differently when I consider myself a Christian 1st and an American 2nd. We call this a Christian Worldview, and it is something more Christians need to embrace. Trying to revitalize Christendom, through official governmental pronouncements and symbols like prayer in schools, is a nation centric-view, not a Christ-centered view.
7. Societies with compulsory Christian behavior were NOT more Christian in their outcomes.
History teaches us, clearly, that requiring Christian behavior like baptisms, church attendance, and public confessions doesn't create the thoroughly Christian society that the outward appearance projects. This is not a question of public morality, and has nothing to do with marriage, abortion, or other topics where Christian morality is in conflict with a secular viewpoint. Morality is a different issue that requires a different theological basis. We have already seen from Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Hosea (which Jesus quotes) that insincere public acts of worship have the opposite affect of what is intended by those who do them or require them. This is born out by the clear cut examples of Spain following the Reconquista in which the Inquisition utilized threats and torture to force Muslims and Jews to convert to Christianity, and the more recent example of Dietrich Bonhoeffer's Germany, where nearly everyone was a 'Christian', having been baptized at birth, supporting the Church through taxes, and in his words so fooled by "cheap grace" that their unredeemed hearts still enthralled to sin readily swallowed the godless hatred of the Nazis. Where did the Holocaust occur? In the heart of 'Christian' Europe, with the help of millions of people who would have claimed that they were Christians. Are more examples needed? Calvin's Geneva, where the Church literally ran the town, was not sustainable (and burned heretics at the stake), nor was the Pilgrim's isolated community (Witch Trails being the most well known flaw). As we have seen time and time again with the Amish, compelled behavior leads to rebellion, even among those who do believe.
8. Our ancestors in the faith died as martyrs to governments that tried to compel them to not worship, or to worship against their conscience; how can we do that to anyone else?
As a Baptist, this is the final nail in the coffin regarding mandated/compulsory prayer in public schools. The Roman Empire persecuted Christians because they would not worship the Emperor, murdering untold numbers of them, often in purposefully cruel ways. During the Reformation, and especially during the horrors of the Thirty Years War, Catholics, Lutherans, and Reformed Christians all were willing to persecute the
Anabaptists who insistence upon believer baptism (the idea that the Church is not everyone in town, only those who demonstrate genuine faith) offended all sides equally. Many of them were drowned in rivers, by those claiming to be 'good Christians' in mockery of their embrace of immersion baptism. Sadly, years later when the Puritans came to America and finally had power over their own society, they immediately began persecuting anyone showing signs of dissent. The United States of America was a bold social experiment in that at the time it was one of the few nations in the history of the world to not have an official state religion. More than that, religious tolerance was enshrined in the Bill of Rights, protecting the Church from the State, and the State from the Church.
I find it ironic that many of the same voices crying out for a ban on Sharia Law in the United States (where it is not even a remote possibility with the Muslim population at 1%), and who, correctly, decry the oppression faced by our brothers and sisters in Christ in Muslim countries and in Communist China, will then turn around and call for the shoe to be on the other foot here in America. The degree of compulsion may not be the same, nor the penalties for stepping out of line, but the idea of mandating religious behavior is. What is morally wrong in other countries ought to be morally wrong here as well.
Kids and teachers pray in school every day that the school is in session, when they choose to. God is not asking us to pretend that America is a Christian nation through insincere public acts, but to transform our families, churches, and communities through deep commitments to righteous living and sustained efforts at evangelism. What will propel the Church in America forward is not policies foisted upon an unwilling or indifferent public, but sincere worship, servant's hearts, and morally upright living on the part of God's people. If you want to transform America, start with the Church.
